No you're not. You're just making shit up to justify moving the goal posts.

When I see a bear in the woods am I supposed to extrapolate that it is a mama bear and there are cubs nearby? If it is spring/early summer the odds of that are quite high. Of course not.

The "thought experiment" was explicit. One man or one bear. Then one Diddy or one bear.

You continue to try to apply the results of a second thought experiment to the first one. I refuse because it is a different thought experiment.

If you want to have a different thought experiment and NOT the first one, then say that. I don't accept the switch mid-discussion.